Comments on: Cask Ale https://allaboutbeer.net/learn-beer/styles/styles-features/2010/05/cask-ale/ Celebrating the World of Beer Culture Fri, 20 Sep 2013 23:21:31 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0.1 By: KevinTran https://allaboutbeer.net/learn-beer/styles/styles-features/2010/05/cask-ale/comment-page-2/#comment-9446 KevinTran Sat, 27 Jul 2013 08:25:38 +0000 https://allaboutbeer.net/?p=14917#comment-9446 Nice post Nice post

]]>
By: Cask Ale » Keeping it Real | Amsterdam Rhino https://allaboutbeer.net/learn-beer/styles/styles-features/2010/05/cask-ale/comment-page-1/#comment-8774 Cask Ale » Keeping it Real | Amsterdam Rhino Tue, 04 Jun 2013 22:03:20 +0000 https://allaboutbeer.net/?p=14917#comment-8774 [...] you to Steve Hamburg of All About Beer Magazine for this article. Book NowLock down your night out by getting on our guest list, reserving a [...] [...] you to Steve Hamburg of All About Beer Magazine for this article. Book NowLock down your night out by getting on our guest list, reserving a [...]

]]>
By: Resolutions v 2.0 | MetaCookbook https://allaboutbeer.net/learn-beer/styles/styles-features/2010/05/cask-ale/comment-page-1/#comment-6140 Resolutions v 2.0 | MetaCookbook Wed, 16 Jan 2013 13:03:23 +0000 https://allaboutbeer.net/?p=14917#comment-6140 [...] curious about what “cask” beer means, Wikipedia has a nice article on it. So does All About Beer magazine. Both indicate there’s a possibility that a place advertising [...] [...] curious about what “cask” beer means, Wikipedia has a nice article on it. So does All About Beer magazine. Both indicate there’s a possibility that a place advertising [...]

]]>
By: Mike Nimro https://allaboutbeer.net/learn-beer/styles/styles-features/2010/05/cask-ale/comment-page-1/#comment-176 Mike Nimro Wed, 30 Jun 2010 18:59:07 +0000 https://allaboutbeer.net/?p=14917#comment-176 I disagree. If the auther was writing, as you are, about "a beer", then perhaps you have a point. However, he is writing specifically about cask ales/beers. More to the point, True Cask Conditioned Ales/Beers. "A beer" can be applied to just about any carbonated alcoholic liquid-in-a-can, such as "the beast" (milwaukee's best). If you'll pardon the phrase... "this ain't that". Rather than trying to homogenize everything down to the lowest common denominator so that "everyone can be a winner (without having to try too hard)", I for one would love to shrug off these Gen-Me-esque concepts and strive for excellence if that is what you'd like to do. The Chevy Malibu is an ok vehicle ("a car"). However, it's no Ferrari and rightly so. Just don't try to dumb-down Ferrari simply because Chevy either isn't capable to this level of quality or isn't interested in trying. I disagree.
If the auther was writing, as you are, about “a beer”, then perhaps you have a point.
However, he is writing specifically about cask ales/beers. More to the point, True Cask Conditioned Ales/Beers.

“A beer” can be applied to just about any carbonated alcoholic liquid-in-a-can, such as “the beast” (milwaukee’s best).
If you’ll pardon the phrase… “this ain’t that”.

Rather than trying to homogenize everything down to the lowest common denominator so that “everyone can be a winner (without having to try too hard)”, I for one would love to shrug off these Gen-Me-esque concepts and strive for excellence if that is what you’d like to do.

The Chevy Malibu is an ok vehicle (“a car”).
However, it’s no Ferrari and rightly so.
Just don’t try to dumb-down Ferrari simply because Chevy either isn’t capable to this level of quality or isn’t interested in trying.

]]>
By: Proper Cask Ale « Mad Fox Brewing Company https://allaboutbeer.net/learn-beer/styles/styles-features/2010/05/cask-ale/comment-page-1/#comment-174 Proper Cask Ale « Mad Fox Brewing Company Wed, 30 Jun 2010 11:57:26 +0000 https://allaboutbeer.net/?p=14917#comment-174 [...] Cask Ale, Keeping it Real - By Steve Hamburg [...] [...] Cask Ale, Keeping it Real - By Steve Hamburg [...]

]]>
By: Chris Schofield https://allaboutbeer.net/learn-beer/styles/styles-features/2010/05/cask-ale/comment-page-1/#comment-159 Chris Schofield Mon, 14 Jun 2010 17:46:31 +0000 https://allaboutbeer.net/?p=14917#comment-159 Don't judge a book by it's cover. Just because a beer is cloudy doesn't mean it's not an excellent beer. Appearance is kinda neat, but it's purely aesthetic and has very little affect on the aspects of beer that matter; flavor, aroma and carbonation (mouthfeel). It really bothers me that the author suggests you send a beer back because it's cloudy. He says "The only exception is if haziness is considered proper for the style of beer being served." The idea of making a decision about a beer based on what is "considered proper for the style" is the final wall the craft brewing industy needs to break down. These systematic rules that some people insist on using to define what is RIGHT and what is WRONG about a beer takes away from the potential creative expression of the brewer and the possibility of a new, unique and enjoyable experiences for the drinker. Everyone needs to calm down a little, expand your minds a bit, get rid of preconceptions and instead of deciding if a beer is what it "should" be or if it's pretty, just decide if you like the actual beer. Don’t judge a book by it’s cover.

Just because a beer is cloudy doesn’t mean it’s not an excellent beer. Appearance is kinda neat, but it’s purely aesthetic and has very little affect on the aspects of beer that matter; flavor, aroma and carbonation (mouthfeel). It really bothers me that the author suggests you send a beer back because it’s cloudy. He says “The only exception is if haziness is considered proper for the style of beer being served.”

The idea of making a decision about a beer based on what is “considered proper for the style” is the final wall the craft brewing industy needs to break down. These systematic rules that some people insist on using to define what is RIGHT and what is WRONG about a beer takes away from the potential creative expression of the brewer and the possibility of a new, unique and enjoyable experiences for the drinker. Everyone needs to calm down a little, expand your minds a bit, get rid of preconceptions and instead of deciding if a beer is what it “should” be or if it’s pretty, just decide if you like the actual beer.

]]>